Last Updated: August 30, 2016 at 8:12 AM

Libertarian Party of Ohio v. Husted

Case Information

Date Filed: September 25, 2013
State: Ohio
Issue: Ballot Access
Courts that Heard this Case: Southern District of Ohio (Case 2:13-CV-00953); United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (Case 14-03030); United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (Case 14-3230); United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (Case 16-3537)

Issue:

Issue 1:

Does Secretary Husted's enforcement of residency requirements for circulators of candidates' nominating petitions  violate the First Amendment?

Issue 2:

Does Secretary Husted's enforcement of residency requirements for circulators of candidates' nominating petitions, as applied,  violate the First Amendment?

Status:

Opinion and Order Granting Summary Judgment to Defendant issued 3/16/15. Opinion and Order finding Ohio minor party ballot access law constitutional filed 10/16/15. Motion for Summary Judgment as to Count 7 by Defendant Husted on 10/30/15. Opinion and order on discovery issues filed 2/5/16. Opinion and order granting summary judgment to defendant filed 5/20/16. Notice of Appeal filed 5/20/16. Appellant's brief filed 6/21/16. State's Appellee brief filed 7/7/16. Gregory Felsoci's Appellee brief filed 7/7/16. Appellant's reply brief filed 7/11/16. Opinion and Judgment affirming District Court filed 7/29/16. Motion to Stay Judgment filed 8/1/16. 6th Circuit Order Denying Motion for Stay filed 8/22/16. Application for Stay and Emergency Injunction filed in U.S. Supreme Court 8/23/16. Order Denying Stay filed 8/29/16.

District Court Documents

• Complaint (filed 9/25/13)
• Ohio's Motion to Intervene (filed 10/3/13)
  • Notice Proposed Defenses (filed 10/3/13)
• Conference Memorandum and Order (filed 10/3/13)
• First Amended Complaint (filed 11/8/13)
• Declaration of Aaron Harris (filed 10/4/13)
• Declaration of Kevin Knedler (filed 10/4/13)
• Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 9/26/13)
• Ohio's Memo Contra to Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 10/18/13)
• Plaintiff's 2nd Motion for Preliminary Injuntion (filed 11/10/13)
• Plaintiff's Reply to Secretary and Ohio's Responses (filed 9/25/13)
• Opinion and Order and Preliminary Injuction (filed 11/14/13)
• First Motion to Intervene by Hart et al (filed 11/27/13)
• Defendant Husted's Answer (filed 11/29/13)
• Defendant State of Ohio's Answer (filed 11/29/13)
• Declaration of Richard Winger (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Nelson Roe (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Martin Elsass (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Gregory A. Norris (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Robert Sherwin (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Mark Noble (filed 12/2/13)
• Declaration of Robert Hart (filed 12/2/13)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 12/2/13)
• Intervenor Plaintiffs' Motion for TRO and Preliminary Injunction (filed 12/3/13)
• Defendant Husted's Memorandum in Response (filed 12/4/13)
• Defendant State of Ohio's Memorandum in Response (filed 12/4/13)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Husted's and Ohio's Memoranda (filed 12/8/13)
• Defendants' Notice of Depositions (filed 12/10/13)
• Declaration of Max Russell Erwin (filed 12/10/13)
• Husted Brief on Preliminary Injunction (filed 12/13/13)
• Evidentiary Attachment (filed 12/13/13)
• Filing of Depositions (filed 12/13/13)
• Ohio Memo Contra to Preliminary Injunction (filed 12/13/13)
• Intervenor-Plaintiff's Reply to Memo Contra (filed 12/13/13)
• Hart Complaint (filed 12/23/13)
• Intervenor's Reply Memo to Defendant's Memo Contra (filed 12/23/13)
• Oral Arugment Scheduled for 1/6/14 (filed 12/30/13)
• Opinion and Order Granting Preliminary Injunction (filed 1/7/14)
• Intervenor-Defendant Notice of Filing Supporting Evidence for Memo Contra (filed 1/7/14)
  • Letter from Kneller to Husted (filed 1/7/14)
• Husted Answer and Affirmative Defenses (filed 1/9/14)
• Ohio Answer and Affirmative Defenses (filed 1/9/14)
• Notice of Appeal from Order Granting Preliminary Injunction (filed 1/10/14)
• Notice of Order of Dismissal from Appellate Court (filed 2/24/14)
• Intervenor Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 2/25/14)
• Intervenor Plaintiffs' Memorandum in Support of Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 3 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 4 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 5 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 6 (filed 2/25/14)
  • Exhibit 7 (filed 2/25/14)
• Intervenor Plaintiffs' Attachment of Exhibits for Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 3 (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 4 (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 5 (filed 2/27/14)
  • Exhibit 6 (filed 2/27/14)
• Plaintiff's Amended Complaint (filed 3/7/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 3/7/14)
• Plaintiff's Motion for Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/7/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 3/7/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 3/7/14)
  • Exhibit 3 (filed 3/7/14)
  • Exhibit 4 (filed 3/7/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Motion to Intervene (filed 3/10/14)
  • Proposed Answer (filed 3/10/14)
• Defendant's Notice of Related Case in Ohio Supreme Court (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 3/11/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Response in Opposition to Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit 3 (filed 3/11/14)
• Defendant's Opposition to Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/11/14)
• Defendant's Exhibits for Opposition to Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit A (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit B-1 (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit B-2 (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit C (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit D (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit E (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit F (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit G (filed 3/11/14)
  • Exhibit H (filed 3/11/14)
• Plaintiff's Affidavit in Support of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/13/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 3/13/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Motion to Strike Declaration of Paul Frankel (filed 3/13/14)
• Plaintiff's Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/13/14)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority Supporting Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/13/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Response Regarding Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/16/14)
• Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint (filed 3/16/14)
  • Exhibit 1 (filed 3/16/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 3/16/14)
• Intervenor-Applicant's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File Third Amended Complaint (filed 3/16/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 3/17/14)
  • Proposed Order (filed 3/17/14)
• Plaintiffs' Supplemental Memorandum Supporting Motion for Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/18/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Brief (filed 3/18/14)
• Defendant's Brief (filed 3/18/14)
• Opinion and Order denying Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 3/19/14)
• Motion to Stay Order on Motion for TRO (filed 3/19/14)
• Notice of Appeal as to Order on Motion for TRO (filed 3/19/14)
• Defendant's Response to Motion to Stay TRO (filed 3/20/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendant's Response (filed 3/20/14)
• Order Denying Plaintiffs' Motion to Stay (filed 3/20/14)
• Notice to take deposition of Gregory Felsoci (filed 3/24/14)
• Response to Motion for Leave to File Third Amended Complaint (3/24/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Motion for a Protective Order (3/25/14)
• Motion to Compel Felsoci's Deposition (3/25/14)
  • Brown Declaration
  • Felsoci Transcript
• Order granting plaintiffs leave to file second amended complaint (filed 3/26/14)
• Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint (filed 3/26/14)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 4/3/14)
  • Opinion (filed 4/3/14)
• Defendant's Response in Opposition to Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 4/4/14)
• Intervening-Defendant Felsoci's Answer to Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint (filed 4/8/14)
• Husted's Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 4/9/14)
• State of Ohio's Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 4/9/14)
• Felsoci's Response in Opposition to First Motion to Compel Felsoci's Deposition (filed 4/15/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Felsoci's Response (filed 4/15/14)
• Plaintiffs' Response in Opposition to Motion for Protective Order (filed 4/15/14)
• Reply to Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 4/22/14)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Discovery (filed 5/21/14)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Discovery (filed 5/27/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Withdraw Motion to Amend Second Complaint (filed 6/8/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to filed Third Amended Complaint (filed 6/8/14)
• Plaintiff-Intervenors' Notice of Discovery Requests (filed 6/10/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Deposition (filed 6/16/14)
  • Appendix
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
  • Exhibit 5
  • Exhibit 6
  • Exhibit 7
  • Exhibit 8
• Briefing Order (filed 6/23/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Response to Motion to Compel Depositions and Motion for Protective Order (filed 6/27/14)
• Defendant's Response to Motion for Leave to file Third Amended Complaint (filed 6/30/14)
• Intervenor-Defendant's Response to Motion for Leave to file Third Amended Complaint (filed 6/30/14)
• Defendant's Motion for Protective Order (filed 6/30/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply regarding Motion for Protective Order (filed 7/1/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
  • Exhibit 5
  • Exhibit 6
• Plaintiffs' Reply regarding Motion to Compel (filed 7/1/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
• Intervenor Defendant's Response to Motion for Leave to file Third Amended Complaint (filed 7/1/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply regarding Motion for Leave to file Third Amended Complaint (filed 7/4/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Production from Secretary (filed 7/8/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Production from Felsoci (filed 7/8/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Briefing Order (filed 7/9/14)
• Order Granting Motion to Compel (filed 7/11/14)
• Opinion and Order Granting Motion to Compel (filed 7/14/14)
• Defendants' Response to Motion for Compel (filed 7/16/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
• Intervenor Defendant's Objection to Order (filed 7/16/14)
• Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Objection (filed 7/16/14)
• Plaintiff's Reply to Response to Motion to Compel Production (filed 7/17/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
• Defendant's Objection to Order (filed 7/18/14)
• Plaintiff's Response to Objection (filed 7/18/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Objection to Motion to Compel (Filed 7/21/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Order that Felsoci's Objection is Overruled (filed 7/24/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Response to Motion to Compel (Filed 7/24/14)
  • Exhibit 1
• Order overruling Secretary's Objection to Magistrate's Opinion, granting Plaintiff's motion to compel, and denying Secretary's motion for protective order (filed 7/24/14)
• Defendant's Sur-Reply to Motion to Compel Production (filed 7/25/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Plaintiffs' Reply Motion to Strike (filed 7/28/14)
• Felsoci's Notice of Privilege Log (filed 7/29/14)
  • Privilege Log
• Opinion and Order denying Motion to Compel (filed 7/31/14)
• Plaintiffs' Supplemental Memorandum Motion to Compel Production (filed 8/6/14)
• Intervenor Defendant Supplemental Memorandum (filed 8/6/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Intervenor Defendant Supplemental Memorandum (filed 8/12/14)
  • Exhibit
• Order granting Motion to Compel (filed 8/12/14)
• Intervenor Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 8/15/14)
  • Memorandum in Support
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' First Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 8/18/14)
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Withdrawal of Document (filed 8/19/14)
• Plaintiffs' First Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 8/19/14)
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor-Plaintiffs' Supplemental Declaration (filed 8/22/14)
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' First Motion to Quash Subpoenas Duces Tecum (filed 8/24/14)
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Filing of Deposition (filed 8/25/14)
• Scheduling Order (filed 8/28/14)
• Intervenor-Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Protective Order (filed 8/29/14)
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Expedite Trial Date (filed 8/31/14)
• Plaintiffs' Reply regarding Motion for Protective Order (filed 9/1/14)
• Order regarding transcripts (filed 9/4/14)
• Defendants' Opposition to First Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 9/8/14)
• Defendants' Opposition to First Motion to Expedite (filed 9/8/14)
• Intervenor Defendant Opposition to Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 9/9/14)
  • Attachment A
• Order denying Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 9/9/14)
• Order granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to file Third Amended Complaint (filed 9/10/14)
• Plaintiff's Third Amended Complaint (filed 9/11/14)
• Scheduling Order (filed 9/12/14)
• Plaintiff's Reply to Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 9/14/14)
• Fourth Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 9/15/14)
  • Appendix
• Defendant's Notice of Related Authority (filed 9/15/14)
• Plaintiff's First Motion for Temporary Restraining Order (filed 9/15/14)
  • Appendix
• Scheduling Order (filed 9/16/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Request for Instructions (filed 9/17/14)
  • Exhibit A
• Deposition of Robert Bridges (filed 9/17/14)
  • Transcript
• Deposition of Steven Linnabary (filed 9/17/14)
  • Transcript
• Deposition of Jon Husted (filed 9/17/14)
  • Transcript
• Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 9/17/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
  • Exhibit 5
  • Exhibit 6
  • Exhibit 7
  • Exhibit 8
• Order denying Motion for Instructions (filed 9/18/14)
• Plaintiffs' Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 9/18/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
  • Exhibit 5
  • Exhibit 6
  • Exhibit 7
  • Exhibit 8
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Subpoenas (filed 9/18/14)
  • Exhibit A
  • Exhibit B
• Intervenor Defendant's Response to Motion for TRO (filed 9/18/14)
• Exhibit 1
• Exhibit 2
• Defendant's Response to Motion for TRO (filed 9/18/14)
• Declaration in Support of Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 9/19/14)
  • Declaration of Timonthy A. Ward
• Plaintiff's Reply to Response to Motion for TRO (filed 9/19/14)
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
• Defendant's Reply regarding Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 9/23/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
  • Exhibit 3
  • Exhibit 4
  • Exhibit 5
  • Exhibit 6
• Plaintiff's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply (filed 9/23/14)
  • Appendix
• Plaintiff's Witness List (filed 9/23/14)
• Plaintiff's Exhibit List (filed 9/23/14)
  • Appendix
• Notice of filing of Deposition of Brandi Seskes (filed 9/24/14)
  • Deposition
• Notice of filing of Deposition of Bradley Smith (filed 9/24/14)
  • Deposition
• Notice of filing of Deposition of Jack Christopher (filed 9/24/14)
  • Deposition
• Order denying Plaintiff's Motion for TRO (filed 9/24/14)
• Notice of filing of Deposition of Charles Earl (filed 9/24/14)
  • Deposition
• Deposition of Matthew Damschroder (filed 9/24/14)
• Defendant's Exhibit and Witness List (filed 9/24/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Witness List (filed 9/24/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Exhibit List (filed 9/24/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Attach Exhibits (filed 9/25/14)
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor-Defendant's Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 9/25/14)
• Defendant's Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 9/25/14)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Amend Witness List (filed 9/25/14)
• Plaintiffs' Second Motion to Attach Exhibits (filed 9/25/14)
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' Third Motion to Attach Exhibits (filed 9/25/14)
  • Exhibit
• Plaintiffs' Fourth Motion to Attach Exhibits (filed 9/26/14)
  • Exhibit
• Deposition of Terry Casey (filed 9/26/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Response First Motion to Amend (filed 9/26/14)
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor Defendant's Response to Fourth Motion to Amend (filed 9/26/14)
• Knedler Deposition (filed 9/26/14)
• Harris Deposition (filed 9/26/14)
• Winnett Deposition (filed 9/26/14)
• DeMora Deposition (filed 9/26/14)
• Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 9/29/14)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 9/29/14)
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor Defendant's Objections to Hearing Exhibits (filed 10/1/14)
• Plaintiff's Objection to Intervenor Defendant's Objections (filed 10/1/14)
• Intervenor-Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Objection (filed 10/1/14)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 10/1/14)
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor Defendant's Brief (filed 10/3/14)
• Plaintiff's Trial Brief (filed 10/3/14)
  • Appendix
• Defendant's Trial Brief (filed 10/3/14)
• Intervenor-Defendant's Reply regarding Motion for Summary Judgement (filed 10/3/14)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Trial Brief Supplemental Authority (filed 10/13/14)
  • Appendix
• Opinion and Order Denying Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 10/17/14)
• Plaintiff's First Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 10/23/14)
  • Appendix
  • Felsoci Letter
• Defendant's Cross Motion for Summary Judgement (filed 11/13/14)
• Felsoci's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgement (filed 11/13/14)
  • Exhibit A
  • Exhibit B
  • Exhibit C
• Plaintiff's Reply to Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 11/16/14)
  • Exhibit
• Defendant's Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 11/17/14)
• Plaintiff's Reply regarding First Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 11/21/14)
• Intervenor Defendant's Motion for Sanctions (filed 11/24/14)
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Plaintiff's Reply in Opposition to Motion for Sanctions (filed 11/26/14)
  • Exhibit
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor Defendant's Reply to Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 12/03/14)
• Plaintiff's Motion for Leave to file Additional Memorandum (filed 12/04/14)
  • Appendix
• State's Reply in Support of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 12/08/14)
• Order Granting Motion to Quash (filed 12/08/14)
• Plaintiffs' Memo in Sur-Reply Regarding Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 12/09/14)
• Felsoci's Reply in Support of Sanctions (filed 12/15/14)
• Husted's Memo in Opposition to Request for Leave (filed 12/16/14)
• Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions against Intervenor-Defendant (filed 12/23/14)
  • Exhibit
• Intervenor - Defendant's Opposition to First Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 1/05/15)
  • Affidavit of Quintin F. Lindsmith
• Plaintiff's Reply to Response to First Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 1/08/15)
  • Exhibit A
  • Exhibit B
• Order denying Felsoci's Motion to Strike (filed 1/09/15)
• Order denying LPO's Motion for Leave to File (filed 1/09/15)
• Order denying LPO's Motion to Strike (filed 1/09/15)
• Order denying without prejudice to refiling after entry of final judgment (filed 1/09/15)
• Order granting LPO's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply (filed 1/09/15)
• Order granting LPO's Various Motions for Leave to File exhibits (filed 1/09/15)
• Order granting LPO's Motion to Strike (filed 1/09/15)
• Order denying Felsoci's Motion for Sanctions (filed 1/09/15)
• Order granting LPO's Motion for Leave (filed 1/09/15)
• Order granting LPO's Motion for Leave to Memorandums (filed 1/09/15)
• Order denying LPO's Motion for Sanctions (filed 1/09/15)
• Order finding as moot Husted's Motion for Extension of Time (filed 1/13/15)
• Order denying without prejudice to refiling (filed 1/13/15)
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 2/12/15)
• Defendant's Motion to Strike Supplemental Authority (filed 2/12/15)
• Plaintiff's Response to Motion to Strike Supplemental Authority (filed 2/13/15)
  • Exhibit A
• Plaintiff's First Motion to Maintain Status Quo (filed 2/27/15)
  • Exhibit A
• Opinion and Order Granting Summary Judgment to Defendant (filed 3/16/15)
• Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's First Motion to Maintain Status Quo (filed 3/20/15)
• Plaintiff's Reply regarding Motion to Maintain Status Quo (filed 3/20/15)
• Plaintiff Intervenors' Second Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 3/30/15)
  • Memorandum in Support
  • Exhibit 1
  • Exhibit 2
• Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 4/8/15)
  • Exhibit
• Defendant's Motion to Strike (filed 4/15/15)
• Plaintiffs' Opposition to Motion to Strike ( filed 4/15/15)
• Defendant's Reply to Response to Motion to Strike (filed 4/21/15)
• Order denying Plaintiff-Intervenor's Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 4/22/15)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to file Sur-Reply (filed 4/22/15)
  • Appendix Sur-Reply
• Order vacating April 22 Order (filed 5/4/15)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Supplement Record in Support of Summary Judgment Motion (filed 5/19/15)
• Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion to Supplement Record (filed 5/27/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion to Supplement Record (filed 5/29/15)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Defendant to Produce Documents and Memorandum in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion (filed 6/12/15)
• Discovery Conference held on 6/17/2015
• Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 37 (filed 6/20/15)
• Transcript of Proceedings- Testimony of Matthew Borges from 3/17/2014 (filed 6/22/15) (Document Not Available)
• Motion to Compel Production Under Rule 45 from a Non-Party, Mr. Matt Borges (filed 6/26/15)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 6/29/15)
• Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel (filed 6/29/15)
• Order Striking 281, 289, and 303 Supplemental Authorities (filed 7/06/15)
• Consolidated Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motions (filed 7/06/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Intervenor-Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel and Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions (filed 7/08/15)
• Defendant Husted's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 37 (filed 7/13/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendant Husted's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 37 (filed 7/13/15)
• Non-Party Matt Borges's Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Compel Production (filed 7/17/15)
• Motion for Leave to File the Attached Memorandum in Opposition Nunc Pro Tunc (filed 7/17/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Matt Borges's Response (filed 7/18/15)
• Non-Party Matt Borges's Notice of Filing His Declaration and the Declaration of Thomas Dains, Jr. (filed 7/22/15)
• Plaintiffs' Motion to Strike Non-Party Borges's Notice of Filing of Affidavits (filed 7/24/15)
• Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to Depose Intervenor-Defendant Felsoci and Motion to Compel Felsoci's Deposition (filed 8/07/15)
• Non-Party Matt Borges's Reply to Plaintiffs' Motion to Strike (filed 8/14/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Non-Party Matt Borges's Response (filed 8/14/15)
• Request for Status Conference (filed 8/21/15)
• Status Conference held on 8/27/15 (No Document of Transcript Available)
• Consolidated Memorandum of Intervening Defendant Felsoci (filed 8/31/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Intervenor-Defendant Felsoci's Response (filed 9/01/15)
• Court Order (filed 9/02/15)
• Court Order on Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel a Response Directed to Matt Borges (filed 9/04/15)
• Notice of Deposition of Felsoci (filed 9/09/15)
• Notice of Deposition of Casey (filed 9/09/15)
• Plaintiffs' Renewed Motion to Compel Production from Matt Borges (filed 9/11/15)
• Borges's Memorandum in Opposition to Renewed Motion to Compel Production (filed 9/17/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Borges's Response to Plaintiffs' Renewed Motion to Compel (filed 9/17/15)
• Motion to Compel Production from a Non-Party, Terry Casey (filed 9/18/15)
• ORDER - Mr. Casey shall file a response to Motion to Compel (filed 9/22/15)
• Memorandum of Casey in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel (filed 9/25/15)
• Plaintiffs' Reply to Casey's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Production Under Rule 45 (filed 9/25/15)
• Plaintiffs' Omnibus Motion to Supplement Record (filed 10/12/15)
• OPINION and ORDER granting in part and denying in part Defendant & Plaintiffs' Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 10/14/15)
• ORDER - Briefing schedule as to Count 7 of Plaintiffs' amended complaint (filed 10/16/15)
• Plaintiffs' renewed MOTION for Summary Judgment Under Count Seven (filed 10/16/15)
• MOTION for Entry of Judgment (filed 10/23/15)
• MOTION for Summary Judgment as to Count 7 by Defendant Husted (filed 10/30/15)
• Cross MOTION for Summary Judgment by Intervenor Defendant Gregory A Felsoci (filed 10/30/15)
• RESPONSE in Opposition Re: MOTION for Summary Judgment Under Count Seven and in Support of Felsoci's Cross Motion (filed 10/30/15)
• Plaintiffs' Response To Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment Under Count Seven (filed 11/02/15)
• RESPONSE in Opposition to MOTION for Entry of Judgment (filed 11/06/15)
• REPLY to Response in Opposition to MOTION for Entry of Judgment (filed 11/06/15)
• REPLY to Response to Motion for Summary Judgment as to Count Seven (filed 11/09/15)
• REPLY to Response to Cross MOTION for Summary Judgment (filed 11/09/15)
• MOTION to Stay Pending Appeal and Emergency Injunction re: Order on Motion for Summary Judgment, by Plaintiffs (filed 11/18/15)
• NOTICE OF APPEAL as to Order on Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 11/19/15)
• ORDER of USCA (filed 12/09/15)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 12/16/15)
  • Secretary of State Directive (filed 12/16/15)
• Court of Appeals Order Denying Plaintiffs' Motion to Disqualify (filed 12/23/15)
• Opinion and Order (filed 02/05/16)
• NOTICE by Plaintiff re: MOTION for Summary Judgment Under Count Seven Supplemental Authority (filed 02/05/16)
  • Appendix
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 03/25/16)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Supplemental Authority in support of Count Seven (filed 04/28/16)
• NOTICE by Plaintiff for Summary Judgment Under Count Seven Supplemental Authority (filed 05/05/16)
  • Exhibit Veasey v. Abbott
• Opinion and Order (filed 5/20/16)
• Judgment (filed 5/20/16)
• Motion to Stay Pending Appeal and Emergency Injunction Pending Appeal (filed 5/20/16)
• Notice of Appeal (filed 5/20/16)
• Response to Motion to Stay (filed 6/10/16)
• Order denying Motion to Stay (filed 6/10/16)
• Second Renewal of Motion for Attorney Fees (and original supporting documents) (filed 6/29/16)
• Memorandum in Support of Second Renewed Motion by Plaintiffs (filed 6/29/16)
• First Motion for Attorney Fees and Affidavits (filed 6/30/16)
• Second Motion for Attorney Fees (filed 6/30/16)
• Second Motion for Attorney Fees from Felsoci and Declarations (filed 6/30/16)

Court of Appeals Documents

• Civil Case Docket (filed 1/10/14)
• Defendants' Motion to Expedite (filed 1/10/14)
• Libertarian Party of Ohio's Corporate Disclosure Statement (filed 1/10/14)
• Plaintiffs' Response to Motion to Expedite (filed 1/10/14)
• Plaintiffs' Corporate Disclosure Statement (filed 1/13/14)
• Intervenor-Plaintiffs' Response to Motion to Expedite (filed 1/13/14)
• Order denying Motion to Expedite (filed 1/15/14)
• Briefing Schedule (filed 1/16/14)
• Defendant's Civil Appeal Statement of Parties and Issues (filed 1/27/14)
• Mediation Office's Letter (filed 2/14/14)
• Defendant's Stipulation to dismiss (filed 2/18/14)
• Order Granting Stipulation to dismiss (filed 2/21/14)
• Letter sent to panel (filed 3/24/14)

Court of Appeals Documents (as to denial of TRO)

• Civil Case Docket (filed 3/20/14)
• Motion for Emergency Injunction and Expedited Appeal (filed 3/20/14)
• Libertarian Party's Corporate Disclosure Statement (filed 3/20/14)
• Libertarian Party's Statement of Parties and Issues (filed 3/20/14)
• Felsoci's Corporate Disclosure Statement (filed 3/20/14)
• Felsoci's Response in Opposition to Motion to Stay (filed 3/21/14)
• Husted's Response in Opposition to Motion to Stay (filed 3/21/14)
• Order denying motion to stay, granting expedited appeal (filed 3/21/14)
• Briefing Schedule (filed 3/21/14)
• Libertarian Party's Brief (filed 3/30/14)
• Notice of Additional Authority (filed 4/3/14)
• Felsoci's Brief (filed 4/10/14)
• Felsoci's motion to dismiss case based on appeal waiver (filed 4/10/14)
• Felsoci's Exhibits Appendix (filed 4/10/14)
• Response in Opposition of Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/10/14)
• Libertarian Party's Motion to Strike Felsoci's Appendix (filed 4/11/14)
• Libertarian Party's Reply Brief (filed 4/13/14)
• Felsoci's Reply (filed 4/14/14)
• Additional Citation filed by Libertarian Party (filed 4/14/14)
• Felsoci's Response in Opposition to Motion to Strike Appendix (filed 4/14/14)
• Libertarian Party's Reply to Opposition to Motion to Strike Appendix (filed 4/14/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 4/18/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 4/18/14)
• Felsoci's Additional Citation (filed 4/21/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 4/22/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 4/22/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 4/23/14)
• Opinion and Order Affirming District Court's Denial of Libertarian Party's Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 5/1/14)
• Libertarian Party's Motion for Stay and Emergency Injunctive Relief (filed 5/1/14)
• Felsoci's Memo in Opposition to Motion for Stay (filed 5/1/14)
• Order Denying Stay Request (filed 5/1/14)
• Libertarian Party's Petition for en banc Rehearing (filed 5/10/14)
• Libertarian Party's Additional Citation (filed 5/26/14)
• Order denying en banc hearing (filed 6/4/14)
• Mandate (filed 6/12/14)

 

Court of Appeals Documents (Third Appeal)

• Civil Case Docketed (filed 11/19/15)
• Appellants' Motion for Emergency Injunction and Expedited Appeal (filed 11/20/15)
• Civil Appeal Statement of Parties and Issues (filed 11/20/15)
• Motion to dismiss case for lack of jurisdiction (filed 11/24/15)
• Response in opposition regarding motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (filed 11/24/15)
• Response in opposition regarding motion for injunction pending appeal (filed 11/25/15)
• Appellants' reply to response regarding Motion for Emergency Injunction and Expedited Appeal (filed 11/25/15)
• Appellees' Reply to Appellants' opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 11/30/15)
• Order: The State's motion to dismiss is denied as moot (filed 12/09/15)

 

Court of Appeals Documents (Subsequent Appeal)

• Appellants' Brief (filed 6/21/16)
• State's Appellee Brief (filed 7/7/16)
• Felsoci's Appellee Brief (filed 7/7/16)
• Appellants' Reply Brief (filed 7/11/16)
• Opinion and Judgment Affirming District Court (filed 7/29/16)
• Motion to Stay Judgment (filed 8/1/16)
• Felsoci's Memo in Opposition to Motion to Stay (filed 8/8/16)
• State's Response in Opposition to Motion to Stay (filed 8/8/16)
• Order Denying Motion to Stay Mandate (filed 8/22/16)

 

U.S. Supreme Court Documents

• Application for Stay and Emergency Injunction (filed 8/23/16)
• Response to Stay Application (filed 8/25/16)
• Reply in Support of Stay (filed 8/26/16)
• Order Denying Stay (filed 8/29/16)