Last Updated: July 31, 2013 at 11:13 AM
Florida v. US
Case Information
Date Filed: August 1, 2011
State: Florida
Issues: Voter Registration, Early Voting
Courts that Heard this Case: The United States District Court for the District of Columbia (Case 1:11-cv-1428 )
Issue:
Whether certain sections of Florida's newly-passed voting reforms violates Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act.
Status:
Complaint filed 8/01/11. Answer filed 10/19/11. Motion for Summary Judgment filed 5/23/12. Opinion issued 8/16/12. Joint Status Report filed 9/25/12.
See also League of Women Voters of Florida v. Browning
District Court Documents
- Complaint
(filed 8/1/11) - Application for 3-Judge Court
(filed 8/1/11) - Order Granting 3 Judge Panel
(filed 8/9/11) - Motion for Leave to Intervene by Sullivan
(filed 8/30/11) - Motion to Intervene by La Raza and League of Women Voters
(filed 9/9/11) - Attorney General's Response to Motion to Intervene
(filed 9/13/11) - State of Florida's Opposition to Motion to Intervene
(filed 9/16/11) - NAACP's Motion in Support of Intervention
(filed 9/20/11) - La Raza's Motion in Support of Intervention
(filed 9/23/11) - Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment
(filed 10/11/11) - Answer to Complaint
(filed 10/19/11) - Order Granting Motion to Intervene
(filed 10/19/11) - Answer to Complaint by NAACP
(filed 10/19/11) - Answer to Complaint by La Raza
(filed 10/19/11) - Second Amended Complaint
(filed 10/25/11) - Answer to Second Complaint by NAACP
(filed 10/28/11) - Answer to Second Complaint by Attorney General
(filed 10/28/11) - Motion for Protective Order on Governing Confidential Information
(filed 12/22/11) - Order Granting Motion for Protective Order
(filed 12/29/11) - Notice of Ancillary Proceedings
(filed 1/25/12) - Motion to Compel the Deposition of Florida Secretary of State Browning
(filed 2/13/12) - Opposition to Motion to Compel the Deposition of Florida Secretary of State Browning
(filed 2/14/12) - Reply to Opposition to Motion to Compel the Deposition of Florida Secretary of State Browning
(filed 2/15/12) - Opinion and Order Regarding Motion to Compel the Deposition of Florida Secretary of State Browning
(filed 2/16/12) - Jointly Stipulated Facts
(filed 3/05/12)
- Exhibits 1-38
(filed 3/05/12)
- Exhibits 1-38
- Stipulation of Dismissal of Second Amended Complaint
(filed 3/23/12) - Joint Stipulated Facts
(filed 4/13/12)
- Exhibits 1-61
(filed 4/13/12)
- Exhibits 1-61
- Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/3/12) - Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12)
- Appendix Volume 18 Part 1 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 2 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 3 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 4 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 5 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 6 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 7 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 18 Part 8 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 19 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 20 Part 1 to Reply to
Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 20 Part 2 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 20 Part 3 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12) - Appendix Volume 20 Part 4 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/18/12)
- Appendix Volume 18 Part 1 to Reply to Proposed Findings of Fact
- State of Florida's Motion for Summary Judgment on Counts 5 and 6
(filed 5/23/12) - United States' and Defendant-Intervenors' Joint Reply Concerning Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 5/24/12) - United States' Motion to Modify Scheduling Order
(filed 5/31/12) - U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson's Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
(filed 6/1/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Notice of Ancillary Proceedings (Browning)
(filed 6/1/12) - Florida's Opposition for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
(filed 6/1/12) - Court Order on Motion to Modify
(filed 6/5/12) - Bill Nelson's Reply Memorandum
(filed 6/5/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Statement Describing the Effects of the Browning Court's Order
(filed 6/12/12) - Florida's Statement Regarding Browning Court's Order
(filed 6/12/12) - United States' Statement Regarding Browning Court's Order
(filed 6/12/12) - Court Order Denying Senator Nelson's Motion to File an Amici Curiae Brief
(filed 6/14/12) - Sen. Nelson's Renewed Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief
(filed 6/15/12) - United States' Response to Court's June 13 Order
(filed 6/18/12) - Scheduling Order
(filed 6/22/12) - Brief of Sen. Bill Nelson as Amicus Curiae in Support of Defendants
(filed 6/22/12) - Memorandum of Law Supporting Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 6/25/12) - Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 6/25/12) - Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Response to Florida's Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 6/25/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 6/25/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Statement Regarding Court's Authority to Grant Conditional Preclearance
(filed 6/29/12) - United States' Notice in Response to June 22, 2012 Court Order
(filed 6/29/12)
- 1997 Texas VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 1999 Alabama VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2002 Alabama VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2003 Texas VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2005 Texas VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2006 Florida VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2009 Texas VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12) - 2011 Georgia VRA Material
(filed 6/29/12)
- 1997 Texas VRA Material
- Notice of Filing of Documents Related to Inter-County Address Changes at the Polls
(filed 6/29/12) - United States' Response to Section 3c of June 22, 2012 Court Order
(filed 6/29/12) - Florida's Position on Court's Authority to Grant Conditional Preclearance
(filed 6/29/12) - Notice of Appeal of Preliminary Injunction in Browning
(filed 7/3/12) - Florida's Response to Court Order
(filed 7/6/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Supplemental Brief Regarding Preclearance Standards
(filed 7/6/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Supplemental Brief Regarding Early Voting Hours Changes
(filed 7/6/12) - United States' Response to Court Order
(filed 7/6/12) - United States' Response Regarding Preclearance
(filed 7/6/12) - Reply Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 7/9/12) - Consolidated Reply Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 7/20/12) - Reply Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Defendant-Intervenors' Cross Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 7/20/12) - Motion for Leave to Amend the Complaint
(filed 8/10/12) - Scheduling Order
(filed 8/13/12) - Florida's Third Amended Complaint
(filed 8/15/12) - Court Order Entering Judgments on Counts 2 and 3
(filed 8/16/12) - Per Curiam Opinion
(filed 8/16/12) - United States' Notice to the Court
(filed 8/22/12) - Motion to Amend Complaint and Supporting Memorandum
(filed 8/22/12) - Motion for Judgment on Count 4
(filed 8/22/12) - Motion to Shorten Time to Respond
(filed 8/27/12) - United States' Opposition to Florida's Motion to Shorten Time to Respond
(filed 8/28/12) - Stipulation of Dismissal as to Count One
(filed 8/28/12) - Declaration of Harry L. Sawyer
(filed 8/31/12) - United States' Response to Florida's Motion for Judgment on Count 4
(filed 9/5/12) - Court Order on Administrative Preclearance Review
(filed 9/6/12) - Notice of Submission of Early Voting Changes for Administrative Preclearance
(filed 9/7/12) - Notice of Attorney General's Determination on Florida's Submission
(filed 9/12/12) - Joint Status Report
(filed 9/25/12) - Stipulation of Dismissal
(filed 10/15/12) - Final Judgment and Order
(filed 10/16/12)


Commentary
Gerrymandering as Viewpoint Discrimination: A "Functional Equivalence" Test
Edward B. Foley
A First Amendment test for identifying when a map is functionally equivalent to a facially discriminatory statute.
more commentary...