Last Updated: September 12, 2014 at 4:39 PM

Favors v. Cuomo

Case Information

Date Filed: November 17, 2011
State: New York
Issue: Redistricting
Courts that Heard this Case: United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York (Case 1:11-cv-05632 )

Issue:

Whether New York's redistricting procedure violates the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the 14th Amendment, among other provisions.

Status:

Complaint filed 11/17/11. Motion to Dismiss Denied 5/16/12. Answer to Cross Claim filed 6/18/12. Assembly Majority's Motion for Summary Judgment on Equal Population claims and section 2 claims filed 6/29/12. Stipulation of Dismissal of Voting Rights Act Section 2 claims against Assembly defendants filed 12/18/12. Final Judgment Order filed 11/5/13. Amended Judgment Order filed 11/8/13. Order granting Motion for Summary Judgment filed 5/22/14. Plaintiff-Intervenors' First Motion for Reconsideration filed 6/4/14. Defendants' Objection to Magistrate's Report and Recommendation filed 6/6/14. Order denying Motion for Reconsideration filed 7/25/14. Order adopting Report and Recommendation filed 8/14/14. Order closing Case filed 8/14/14. Order that Clerk enter Judgment filed 9/5/14. Clerk's Order in favor of the Senate majority filed 9/11/14.

District Court Documents

• Complaint (filed 11/17/11)
• Letter Requesting a Three Judge Panel (filed 12/02/11)
• Notice of Certain Defendants' Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Complaint (filed 12/12/11)
• Motion to Intervene (filed 12/19/11)
• Plaintiffs' Letter to Judge Regarding Motion to Dismiss (filed 12/27/11)
• Plaintiffs' Notice of Voluntary Dismissal of Defendant Schneiderman (filed 12/28/11)
• Motion to Intervene by Asian American Citizens (filed 12/28/11)
• Memorandum in Support of Motion to Intervene (filed 12/28/11)
• Motion to Dismiss of Defendant Kolb (filed 12/28/11)
• Motion to Dismiss of Defendant Oaks (filed 12/28/11)
• Plaintiffs' Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 12/29/12)
• Plaintiffs' Declaration in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 12/29/12)
• Certain Defendants' Response to Motion to Intervene (filed 1/06/12)
• Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss (filed 1/09/12)
• Declaration Regarding Other Cases (filed 1/09/12)
• Certain Defendants' Response to Motion to Intervene by Ramos (filed 1/13/12)
• Certain Defendants' Response to Motion to Intervene by Lee (filed 1/13/12)
• Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Dismiss (filed 1/17/12)
• Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants Sampson and Dilan's Motion to Dismiss (filed 1/17/12)
• Affidavit of Dilan in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 1/17/12)
• Notification of Actions in Similar Case (filed 1/30/12)
• Notification of Dismissal of Counts V and VI (filed 1/30/12)
• Letter Responding to Notification of Actions in Similar Case (filed 1/31/12)
• Letter Regarding Primary Date (filed 2/10/12)
• Motion to Intervene (filed 2/15/12)
• Memorandum of Law in Support of Appointment of Special Master (filed 2/17/12)
• Declaration of Daniel Burstein (filed 2/17/12)
• Certain Defendants' Response to Motion to Intervene (filed 2/17/12)
• Letter Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 2/29/12)
• Letter Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 2/29/12)
• Letter Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 2/29/12)
• Letter Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 2/29/12)
• Letter Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 2/29/12)
• Declaration of Andrew Beveridge, Ph.D. (filed 2/29/12)
• Memorandum on Proposed Map (filed 2/29/12)
• Ramos' Proposed Redistricting Map (filed 2/29/12)
• First Redistricting Map (filed 3/01/12)
• Second Redistricting Map (filed 3/01/12)
• Third Redistricting Map (filed 3/01/12)
• Assembly Majority's Memo Regarding Plan (filed 3/01/12)
• William Farr's Memorandum of Law in Response to Parties' Proposed Redistricting Plans (filed 3/01/12)
• Lee Intervenor's Response (filed 3/02/12)
• Defendant Skelos' Response (filed 3/02/12)
• Rose Intervenors' Response (filed 3/02/12)
• Minority Leader Brian Kolb's Response (filed 3/02/12)
• Ramos Intervenor's Response (filed 3/02/12)
• Drayton's Response (filed 3/03/12)
• Second Declaration of Andrew Beveridge (filed 3/03/12)
• Expert Testimony of Simmons (filed 3/05/12)
• Expert Testimony of Ansolabehere (filed 3/05/12)
• Rose Interveners' Brief Regarding Redistricting Plan (filed 3/07/12)
• Skelos' Response Regarding Redistricting (filed 3/07/12)
• Governor Cuomo's Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Speaker Silver's Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Minority Leader Sampson Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Robert Oaks' Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Minority Leader Kolb's Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Defendant Skelos' Answer to Complaint (filed 3/07/12)
• Order Denying Motion to Dismiss (filed 3/08/12)
• Report and Recommendation (filed 3/12/12)
• Ramos-Intervenors' Response to Judge's Redistricting Plan (filed 3/14/12)
• Plaintiff's Memorandum in Support of Adoption of Report and Opposition (filed 3/14/12)
• Senate Majority Defendant's Opposition to Magistrate Judge's Report (filed 3/14/12)
• Non-party in Submission in Response to Report (filed 3/15/12)
• Letter Regarding Update on Legislation (filed 3/15/12)
• Non-Party Submissions in Response to Report and Recommendations (filed 3/19/12)
• Complaint of Intervenors (filed 3/19/12)
• Order Adopting Report and Recommendations (filed 3/19/12)
• Motion to Intervene (filed 3/20/12)
• Amended Complaint of Plaintiff-Intervenor Ullmnan (filed 3/27/12)
• Amended Complaint of Plaintiff-Intervenor Drayton (filed 3/27/12)
• Amended Complaint of Plaintiff-Intervenor Ramos (filed 3/27/12)
• Amended Complaint of Plaintiff-Intervenor Lee (filed 3/27/12)
• Amended Complaint of Plaintiff Favors (filed 3/27/12)
• Letter Regarding Voting Rights Act (filed 3/28/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint of Ullman (filed 4/02/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint of Ramos (filed 4/02/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint of Lee (filed 4/02/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint of Plaintiff (filed 4/02/12)
• Senate Majority's Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/02/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint of Drayton (filed 4/02/12)
• Motion to Dismiss Ullman's Amended Complaint (filed 4/02/12)
• Documents From Related Case (filed 4/03/12)
• Drayton's Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• Senate Minority's Response to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• Declaration of Eric Hecker (filed 4/09/12)
• Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• Ullman's Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• Lee's Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• Skelos' Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (filed 4/09/12)
• The Senate Minority Response (filed 4/12/12)
• Letter From Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund (filed 4/12/12)
• Ramos' Motion for Preliminary Judgment (filed 4/12/12)
• Drayton's Motion for Preliminary Judgment (filed 4/12/12)
• Declaration of McLaughlin (filed 4/12/12)
• Motion to Intervene (filed 4/13/12)
• Opinion in Cohan v. Cuomo (filed 4/13/12)
• Answer to Complaint (filed 4/16/12)
• Supplemental Response to Court's Order (filed 4/17/12)
• Senate Majority's Response to Plaintiffs' Submissions (filed 4/17/12)
• Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 4/17/12)
• Declaration of Todd Geremia (filed 4/17/12)
• Objection to Drayton's Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 4/17/12)
• Declaration of Breitbart (filed 4/26/12)
• Declaration of Gibbs (filed 4/27/12)
• Declaration of Beveridge (filed 4/27/12)
• Declaration of Apotheker (filed 4/27/12)
• Declaration of Geremia (filed 4/27/12)
• Ramos' Memo is Support of Motion for Preliminary Injunction (filed 4/27/12)
• Response to Court Order (filed 4/30/12)
• Motion to Amend (filed 5/1/12)
• Motion to Intervene (filed 5/1/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 5/2/12)
• Response to Apotheker (filed 5/4/12)
• Response to Geremia (filed 5/4/12)
• Memorandum Regarding Privilege Issues (filed 5/4/12)
• Opposition to Breitbart's Motion to Intervene (filed 5/4/12)
• Senate Majority's Response to Show Cause Order (filed 5/4/12)
• Response of Lee Intervenors to Court's April 20 Order (filed 5/4/12)
• Letter in Response to Opposition to Intervention (filed 5/8/12)
• Letter Regarding Preclearance (filed 5/15/12)
• Order Denying Motion to Dismiss (filed 5/16/12)
• Letter Updating Court on Preclearance Case (filed 5/18/12)
• Answer to Amended Complaint (filed 5/23/12)
• Lee Intervenors Motion for Pre-Motion Conference (filed 5/24/12)
• Discovery Order (filed 5/29/12)
• Court Order After Scheduling Conference (filed 5/29/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants Request for Pre-Motion Conference for Summary Judgment Before Discovery (filed 5/30/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants Letter Supporting a Pre-Motion Conference (filed 5/30/12)
• Court's Consent Order (filed 5/31/12)
• Answer to Cross-Claim of Defendants/Cross-Claimants (filed 5/31/12)
• Senate Minority's Opposition to Pre-Discovery Summary Judgment (filed 6/4/12)
• Plaintiff-Intervenors' Opposition to Summary Judgment (filed 6/4/12)
• Lee Intervenors' Opposition to Summary Judgment (filed 6/4/12)
• Plaintiff's Request for Pre-Motion Conference for Final Judgment on Count 3 (filed 6/4/12)
• Ramos Intervenors' Opposition to Summary Judgment (filed 6/4/12)
• Senate Minority's Motion to Compel (filed 6/11/12)
• Memorandum of Law in Support of Senate Minority's Motion to Compel (filed 6/11/12)
• Declaration of Eric Hecker and Supporting Exhibits (filed 6/11/12)
• Lee Intervenors' Letter Joining Senate Minority's Motion to Compel (filed 6/11/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Motion for a Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
  • Assembly Majority Defendants' Memorandum of Law in Support of a Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
• Declaration of Todd R. Geremia (filed 6/18/12)
• Defendant Senator Skelos' Motion to Dismiss Cross-Claim (filed 6/18/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Motion for a Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
  • Senate Majority Defendants' Memorandum of Law in Support of a Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
• Defendants Kolb and Oaks' Motion for a Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
  • Memorandum of Law in Support of Protective Order (filed 6/18/12)
• Cuomo's Answer to Cross-Claim (filed 6/18/12)
• Favors Plaintiff's Letter in Support of Final Judgment on Count III (filed 6/22/12)
• Kolb and Oaks' Response to Motion to Compel (filed 6/25/12)
• Copy of Petitioners' Brief Brief in Cohen v. Cuomo (filed 6/25/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Opposition to Senate Minority's Motion to Compel (filed 6/25/12)
• Drayton Intervenors' Proposed Judgment Order (filed 6/27/12)
• Rose Intervenors' Objection to Proposed Judgment Order (filed 6/27/12)
• Objection to All Proposed Judgments (filed 6/27/12)
• Ramos Intervenors' Proposed Judgment Order (filed 6/27/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Section 2 Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 6/29/12)
  • Supporting Memorandum of Law (filed 6/29/12)
  • Statement of Material Facts in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 6/29/12)
• Kolb and Oaks' Request to Join Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 6/29/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment on Equal Population Claims (filed 6/29/12)
  • Declaration of Todd R. Geremia in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 6/29/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment on Section 2 Claims (filed 6/29/12)
  • Supporting Declaration of Todd R. Geremia (filed 6/29/12)
• Drayton Intervenors' Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for a Protective Order (filed 7/2/12)
• Letters and Data on Prisoner Addresses (filed 7/2/12)
• Reply Memorandum in Support of Senate Minority's Motion to Compel (filed 7/2/12)
• Senate Minority's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Defendant's Motion for a Protective Order (filed 7/2/12)
• Declaration of Martin Dilan (filed 7/2/12)
• Declaration of Eric Hecker (filed 7/2/12)
• Ramos Intervenors' Opposition to Senate Majority's Motion for a Protective Order (filed 7/2/12)
  • Ramos Intervenors' Memorandum of Law (filed 7/2/12)
• Lee Intervenors' Memorandum of Law Regarding Discovery Motions (filed 7/2/12)
• Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Senator Skelos's Motion to Dismiss the Cross-Claim (filed 7/9/12)
  • Declaration of Eric Hecker (filed 7/9/12)
  • Declaration of Martin Dilan (filed 7/9/12)
  • Declaration of John L. Sampson (filed 7/9/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Reply Memorandum of Law in Support of a Motion for a Protective Order on the Ground of Legislative Privilege (filed 7/9/12)
• Kolb and Oaks' Motion in Support of a Protective Order (filed 7/9/12)
• Declaration of Todd R. Geremia (filed 7/9/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Reply in Further Support of their Motion for a Protective Order (filed 7/9/12)
• Drayton Plaintiff-Intervenors' Request to File a 56(d) Motion (filed 7/10/12)
• Senate Minority's Response to Defendants' Motion for a Protective Order (filed 7/11/12)
• Assembly Majority's Opposition to Drayton Intervenors' 56(d) Motion (filed 7/11/12)
• Senate Majority's Response to Senate Minority's Letter (filed 7/11/12)
• Court Order Regarding Privilege Logs (filed 7/12/12)
• Reply in Support of Defendant Skelos's Motion to Dismiss Cross-Claim (filed 7/16/12)
• Declaration of Joan P. Gibbs (filed 7/20/12)
• Plaintiffs-Intervenors' Response to the Senate Majority's Statement of Material Facts (filed 7/20/12)
• Drayton Plaintiffs-Intervenors' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Senate Majority's Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 7/20/12)
• Senate Minority's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 7/20/12)
• Drayton Plaintiffs-Intervenors' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Assembly Majority's Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 7/20/12)
• Senate Minority's Counter-statement of Material Facts (filed 7/20/12)
• Declaration of Todd Breitbart (filed 7/20/12)
• Declaration of Eric Hecker (filed 7/20/12)
• Ramos Intervenors Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Senate Majority's Motions for Summary Judgment (filed 7/20/12)
  • Supporting Declaration of Jackson Chin (filed 7/20/12)
• Ramos Intervenors Stipulation to Withdraw Count 3 (filed 7/20/12)
• Reply Memorandum in Support of Assembly Majority Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 8/3/12)
• Senate Majority's Reply to Ramos Intervenor's Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment on Equal Population Claims (filed 8/3/12)
• Senate Majority's Reply to Senate Minority's Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment on Equal Population Claims (filed 8/3/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants Further Reply in Support of their Motion for Summary Judgment on Section 2 Claims (filed 8/3/12)
• Assembly Minority's Letter in Support of Assembly Majority's Motion for Summary Judgment on Section 2 Claims (filed 8/6/12)
• First Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Second Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Third Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Fourth Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Fifth Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Sixth Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Seventh Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Eighth Installment of Assembly Majority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Supplemental Privilege Logs of Assembly Majority (filed 8/6/12)
• Letter from Assembly Minority Defendants on Privilege (filed 8/6/12)
  • Assembly Minority Privilege Log (filed 8/6/12)
• Order on Motion to Compel (filed 8/10/12)
• Defendants' Response to Court's August 10, 2012 Orders (filed 8/14/12)
• Assembly Minority's Appeal from Magistrate Judge's Order (filed 8/24/12)
• Senate Majority's Objections to Magistrate Judge's Order (filed 8/24/12)
• Declaration of C. Daniel Chill (filed 8/29/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Revised Privilege Log (filed 8/29/12)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Personnel Log (filed 8/29/12)
• Declaration of David Lewis (filed 8/29/12)
• Declaration of Debra A. Levine-Schellace (filed 8/29/12)
• Declaration of Diane Burman (filed 8/29/12)
• Declaration of Louis K. Fisher (filed 8/29/12)
• Kolb and Oaks' Personnel and Privilege Logs (filed 8/29/12)
• Senate Majority Privilege Log Personnel List (filed 8/29/12)
• Assembly Minority Defendant's Revised Privilege Log (filed 8/29/12)
• Notice of Production of Privileged Documents (filed 8/29/12)
• Assembly Minority Defendants' Personnel Log (filed 8/29/12)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Amended Privilege Log (filed 8/29/12)
• Court Order on In Camera Review (filed 9/4/12)
• Senate Minority's Response to the Senate Majority's Objections to Initial Privilege Rulings (filed 9/10/12)
  • Drayton Intervenors' Response (filed 9/10/12)
• Letter in Support of Objections to Magistrate Judge's Order (filed 9/21/12)
• Assembly Majority's Reply in Further Support of Objections Regarding Legislative Privilege (filed 9/24/12)
• Declaration of Todd R. Geremia (filed 9/24/12)
• Senate Majority's Reply in Further Support of Objection to Legislative Privilege Order (filed 9/24/12)
• Senate Majority's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 9/26/12)
• Response to Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 9/27/12)
• Joint Request for Extension of Deadlines (filed 11/5/12)
• Revised Discovery Schedule (filed 11/6/12)
• Stipulation of Dismissal (filed 12/18/12)
• Notice of Effect of Stipulation (filed 12/18/12)
• Memorandum Order Requiring Defendants to Revise Privilege Logs (filed 12/20/12)
• Order for Parties to Reconsider Discovery Requests (filed 12/26/12)
• Drayton Intervenors' Letter Withdrawing Certain Discovery Requests (filed 1/7/13)
• Ramos Intervenors' Letter Maintaining Relevance of Discovery Requests (filed 1/7/13)
• Senate Minority's Continuing Discovery Requests (filed 1/8/13)
• Kolb and Oaks' Response to Privilege Questions (filed 1/14/13)
• Declaration of C. Daniel Chill in Response to December 19 Court Order (filed 1/14/13)
• Declaration of Roman Hedges (filed 1/14/13)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Revised Privilege Log (filed 1/14/13)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Response to Privilege Question (filed 1/14/13)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Notice of Filing Amended Privilege Log (filed 1/14/13)
• Senate Minority's Response to Senate Majority's Letter (filed 1/15/13)
• Senate Minority's Letter on Production Disputes (filed 1/16/13)
• Senate Majority's Privilege Response (filed 1/16/13)
• Senate Majority's Production Dispute Response (filed 1/16/13)
• Senate Majority's Status Update (filed 1/25/13)
  • Senate Minority's Response (filed 1/28/13)
• Discovery Conference Notes (filed 1/31/13)
• Drayton Intervenors' Discovery Request (filed 2/4/13)
• Assembly Majority's Response to Discovery Conference (filed 2/4/13)
• Kolb and Oaks' Response to Discovery Conference (filed 2/4/13)
• Senate Majority's Response to Discovery Conference (filed 2/4/13)
• Joint Update on Discovery (filed 2/7/13)
• Memorandum and Order on Protective Orders (filed 2/8/13)
• Proposed Briefing and Oral Argument Schedule (filed 2/21/13)
• Assembly Majority's Objections to Magistrate Judge's February 8 order (filed 2/25/13)
• Senate Democrats' Objections to February 8 order (filed 2/25/13)
• Declaration and Exhibits (filed 2/25/13)
• Senate Majority's Objections to February 8 order (filed 2/25/13)
• Kolb and Oaks' Objections to February 8 order (filed 2/25/13)
• Response of Plaintiffs Drayton et al to Various Objections to Magistrate Judge's Feb. 8 Order (filed 3/8/13)
• Senate Democratic Conference Response to Senate Republicans' Objections (filed 3/8/13)
• Assembly Majority's Memo in Opposition to Senate Democrats' Limited Objections (filed 3/8/13)
• Senate Majority's Response to Senate Minority's Objections (filed 3/8/13)
• Latino Justice's Reponse to Objections (filed 3/11/13)
• Assembly Majority Defendants' Reply Memorandum in Support of Objections to February 8 order (filed 3/18/13)
• Declaration of Todd R. Geremia (filed 3/18/13)
• Senate Democrats' Reply Memorandum in Support of Objections to February 8 order (filed 3/18/13)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Reply in Support of Objections to February 8 order (filed 3/18/13)
• Schedule for Further Motion Briefs (filed 3/22/13)
• Notice of Motion to Compel (filed 4/10/13)
• Senate Democrats' Motion to Compel (filed 4/10/13)
• Declaration of Eric Hecker in Support of Motion to Compel (filed 4/10/13)
• Ramos Intervenors Motion to Compel (filed 4/10/13)
• Ramos Intervenors Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Compel (filed 4/15/13)
• Senate Majority's Request to Set Expert Discovery Deadlines (filed 4/17/13)
• Kolb and Oaks' Response to Motion to Compel (filed 4/24/13)
• Assembly Majority's Response to Motion to Compel (filed 4/24/13)
• Declaration of Michael Eck (filed 4/24/13)
• Declaration of Valerie L. Collins (filed 4/24/13)
• Senate Majority's Opposition to Motion to Compel (filed 4/24/13)
• Drayton Intervenor's Response to Motion to Compel (filed 4/24/13)
• Ramos Intervenors' Response in Support of a Stay on Expert Discovery (filed 4/25/13)
• Lee Intervenors' Objection to Scheduling Expert Discovery (filed 4/26/13)
• Reply Brief in Further Support of Senate Democrats Motion to Compel (filed 5/1/13)
• Reply Declaration of Eric Hecker (filed 5/1/13)
• Senate Majority's Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 5/17/13)
• Senate Majority's Letter Accompanying Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 5/17/13)
• Intervenor Drayton's Letter in Response to Senate Majority's Letter (filed 5/20/13)
• Ramos Intervenor's Letter Proposing Briefing Schedule (filed 5/31/13)
• Ramos Intervenor's Motion to Compel Production (filed 6/7/13)
• Ramos Intervernor's Amended Motion to Compel Production (filed 6/7/13)
• Defendants' Opposition to Intervenors' Motion to Compel (filed 6/21/13)
• Reply Brief in Further Support of Motion to Compel (filed 7/5/13)
• Telephone Conference Regarding Motion to Compel (filed 7/18/13)
• Minutes from Telephone Conference on Discover (filed 8/13/13)
• Hecker's Thank You Letter to Judge Mann (filed 8/19/13)
• Status Update Letter on Document Database (filed 8/20/13)
  • AlphaLit Budget (filed 8/20/13)
• Order Requiring Filing of Retainer Agreement (filed 8/22/13)
• Memorandum and Order (filed 8/27/13)
• Letter to Judge Mann Regarding Order (filed 8/29/13)
• Declaration of David L. Lewis (filed 8/29/13)
• Defendant's Emergency Motion for Stay of Order or 60 Day Extension of Time to Reply (filed 9/3/13)
• Senate Majority Defendants' Objection to Magistrate Order (filed 9/3/13)
• Letter from Eric Hecker to Court (filed 9/4/13)
• Defendants' Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 9/4/13)
  • Exhibit A: Defendants' Notice of Supplemental Authority (filed 9/4/13)
  • Exhibit B: Letter to Judge Mann (filed 9/4/13)
  • Exhibit C: Letter to Judge Wexler (filed 9/4/13)
  • Exhibit D: Hardial v. Hempstead (filed 9/4/13)
• Scheduling Order (filed 9/6/13)
• Minority Response to Majority's Objections (filed 9/9/13)
• Reply Supporting Objections to Order (filed 9/12/13)
• Reply Supporting Emergency Motion for Stay (filed 9/12/13)
• Stipulation of Dismissal (filed 9/20/13)
• Letter to Judge Mann Requesting Extension (filed 10/2/13)
• Order Granting Partial Extension (filed 10/9/13)
• Letter Complying with Order (filed 10/17/13)
  • Attachment A: Privilege Log (filed 10/17/13)
  • Attachment B: Privilege Log Personnel Sheet (filed 10/17/13)
• Order Requesting Clarification on Section 2 Claims (filed 10/21/13)
• Letter from Ramos-Intervenors Answering Clarifying Order (filed 10/23/13)
• Letter from Drayton Intervenors (filed 10/24/13)
• Letter From Senate Majority Defendants (filed 10/24/13)
• Memorandum and Order Dismissing Senate Minority's Cross-claim (filed 10/29/13)
• Letter from Senate Minority on Oral Argument (filed 10/30/13)
• Order for Missining Discovery and In Camera Review (filed 10/30/13)
• Order Amending and Clarifying Scheduling Order (filed 11/1/13)
• Final Judgment Order (filed 11/5/13)
• Letter Regarding In Camera Review (filed 11/6/13)
• Letter Requesting Pre-Motion Conference (filed 11/7/13)
• Amended Judgment Order (filed 11/8/13)
• Rose Intervenor's Letter Seeking Clarification (filed 11/12/13)
• Summary of Oral Argument (filed 11/13/13)
• Declaration of Marc E. Elias (filed 11/19/13)
• Letter Regarding Plaintiff's Attorney Fees (filed 11/19/13)
• Letter Requesting Extension (filed 11/19/13)
• Notice of Motion for Fees (filed 11/19/13)
• Declaration of Randolph M. Mclaughlin (filed 11/19/13)
• Memorandum In Support of Rose Intervenors' Motion for Fees (filed 11/19/13)
• Notice Rose Intervenor's Motion for Fees (filed 11/19/13)
• Letter Requesting Extension (filed 11/22/13)
• State Defendants' Memorandum in Opposition to Intervenors' Motion for Attorney Fees and Costs (filed 12/2/13)
• Ramos Intervenor's Motion for Attorney's Fees (filed 12/13/13)
• Declaration of James Herschlein (filed 12/19/13)
  • Exhibit A: Itemized Bill (filed 12/19/13)
  • Exhibit B: Biography (filed 12/19/13)
• Drayton Motion for Fees (filed 12/19/13)
• Lee Motion for Fees (filed 12/19/13)
• Lee Memo Supporting Motion for Fees (filed 12/19/13)
• Declaration of Glenn Magpantay (filed 12/22/13)
  • Exhibit A: Time Detail (filed 12/22/13)
  • Exhibit B: Biography (filed 12/22/13)
• Declaration Jerry Vattamala (filed 12/22/13)
• Memorandum in Opposition to All Intervenors' Motions for Attorneys' Fees (filed 1/31/14)
• Drayton's Reply in Support for Attorney's Fees (filed 2/14/14)
• Declaration of Joan P. Gibbs (filed 2/14/14)
• Rose Intervenors' Reply in Support for Attorney's Fees (filed 2/14/14)
• Lee Intervenors' Reply in Support for Attorney's Fees (filed 2/14/14)
  • Certificate of Service (filed 2/14/14)
• Ramos Intervenors' Reply Memorandum to Opposition to Attorney's Fees (filed 2/14/14)
  • Affidavit in Opposition (filed 2/14/14)
  • Exhibit 2 (filed 2/14/14)
  • Exhibit 3 (filed 2/14/14)
  • Exhibit 4 (filed 2/14/14)
• Plaintiff-Intervenors' Report and Recommendations regarding Motion for Attorneys' Fees (filed 5/20/14)
• Order granting Motion for Summary Judgment (filed 5/22/14)
• Freedom of Information Letter (filed 5/27/14)
• Order regarding Freedom of Information Letter (filed 5/27/14)
  • Town of Stillwater Map
• Letter from Plaintiff-Intervenors (filed 6/4/14)
• Plaintiff-Intervenors' First Motion for Reconsideration (filed 6/4/14)
  • Notice of Motion
  • Memorandum in Support
• Letter from Plaintiff-Intervenors (filed 6/4/14)
• Letter from Plaintiff-Intervenors (filed 6/5/14)
• Letter from Favors Plaintiffs, Defendants, and Rose Intervenors (filed 6/5/14)
• Letter from Drayton Intervenors (filed 6/5/14)
• Defendants' Objection to Report and Recommendation of Magistrate (filed 6/6/14)
• Plaintiffs-Intervenors' Response to Defendants' Objection (filed 6/12/14)
• Defendants' Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration (filed 6/20/14)
• Plaintiff-Intervenors' Reply in Opposition to Senate Majority to Plaintiff-Intervenors' Motion for Reconsideration (filed 6/25/14)
• Order denying Motion for Reconsideration (filed 7/25/14)
• Order Adopting Report and Recommendations (filed 8/14/14)
• Order Closing Case (filed 8/14/14)
• Scheduling Order (filed 8/20/14)
• Order that Clerk enter Judgment (filed 9/5/14)
• Clerk's Order in favor of Senate Majority (filed 9/11/14)